Prepared by
David Smail, Vice President
Great Sacandaga Lake Association
Sampling and Analysis performed by
Capital Region Environmental Laboratory
137 Columbia Turnpike
Rensselaer, NY 12144
Lead Technical Director Environmental Laboratory
Brian Collins
(518) 949-2020
Field Technician collecting samples
Brian Collins
Abby Smith
Great Sacandaga Lake Coliform Monitoring Program
The Great Sacandaga Lake Coliform Monitoring Program (GSLCMP) for 2023 was designed to quantify the bacterial water quality at selected locations in the Great Sacandaga Lake and in selected streams that feed the lake.
The coliform sampling of the Great Sacandaga Lake was started in 1991 and has been performed every summer for the past 32 years, except for the year 2020 due to the Covid-19 Pandemic. Public bathing beaches, recreational areas, and feeder streams were the primary focus. Seventeen shoreline locations were sampled in June, and an additional twenty-two samples were taken on August 9, 2023. All of the sampling results have shown that the Great Sacandaga Lake water is within allowable standards for recreational contact.
GSLA has been concerned about potential contamination from Kennyetto Creek. Just upstream of the lake on State Route 30 is Adirondack Animal Land, a potential source of bacteria. In the same area, Lane Winney owns 83 acres at the southern end of the Great Sacandaga Lake. The Town of Mayfield has granted approval for Winney to build a large RV park (more than 200 sites) on his land along Woods Hollow Road. In June, the samples taken from Kennyetto Creek under the RT30 bridge were unsafe for bathing (E. coli >2419.6 per 100 ml). The Kennyetto Creek flows into the Great Sacandaga Lake on a very narrow and shallow bay, locally known as Mussel Harbor. To better understand the impact of the creek and gather historical information before the RV park is built, the August sampling included samples from Mussel Harbor. The sample taken under the RT30 bridge was still unsafe for bathing; however, it significantly improved to E. coli 307.6 per 100 ml.
One of the more popular locations on the lake where boaters go, and swim is Sand Island. Some boaters leave garbage and debris including human waste on the island. The Great Sacandaga Lake Advisory Council has been working for years to be able to put porta potties on the island. Current plans will have them there during the next boating season. On August 9th four samples were taken just off the Sand Island beach for historical baseline data.
Two primary measurements were made at each sampling location: Fecal Coliform (FC) and Escherichia coli (E.coli) Bacteria. These bacteria serve as indicators of the presence of animal or human waste. It should be noted that prior to 2019, the GSLCMP used different primary measurements: Total Coliform (TC) and Fecal Coliform (FC) Bacteria. Total coliforms include bacteria that are found in the soil, in water that has been influenced by surface water runoff, and human or animal waste. Fecal coliforms are the group of total coliforms that are present specifically in the gut and feces of warm-blooded animals. E. coli is a rod-shaped bacterium that is commonly found in the lower intestine of warm-blooded animals. In recent years, scientists believe that the use of FC and E. coli tests provides a better indication of possible contamination than was obtained by using TC and FC analysis.
The presence of elevated levels of these bacteria serves as indicators that potentially disease-causing protozoa, bacteria or other microorganisms may be present in the water.
The presence of elevated levels of these bacteria serves as indicators that potentially disease-causing protozoa, bacteria or other microorganisms may be present in the water.
SUGGESTIONS FOR INTERPERTATION OF COLIFORM DATA
New York State Department of Health has determined the maximum allowable bacterial levels for contact recreation (swimming, wading, etc.). When samples on beaches are exceed allowable levels the New York State Health Department is notified. The Department of Health is empowered to close the location to bathing until the problem or problems are corrected.
Interpretation of data to determine contamination sources (human or other warm-blooded animals) requires more than just the current bacterial levels. Knowledge of the history of the site, weather, geology of the area, drainage patterns, and some information on human activities in the area is also useful. We have sample results from 55 locations that were taken over the past 32 years to help in the interpretation. The locations of the sampling change from year to year. In prior years when the feeder streams were tested, the sample locations were taken under the first bridge upstream from the lake. This location provided easy access to the sampling point; however, because these locations could be several hundred yards upstream of the confluence, some sources of contamination may have been missed. This year, the selected streams were sampled at the confluence of the stream and the Great Sacandaga Lake.
Due to the high turnover rate for the Great Sacandaga Lake the water has seen relatively low contamination levels over the past 30 years.
New York State Fecal Coliform and E. coli
Standards in Waters Used for Contact
Recreation (NYS Dept. of Health)
Maximum Allowable Levels of Coliform Bacteria in Water for Contact Recreation (NYS Dept. of Health) | ||
---|---|---|
Bacterial Test | Max. 5 Sample mean* | Max. Single Result |
Fecal Coliform | 200 per 100 ml | 1000 per 100 ml |
E. coli | 126 per 100 ml | 235 per 100 ml |
*Geometric mean of 5 samples collected within 30 days